NY Property Records
9419 5 Avenue
9419 5 Avenue
Brooklyn · Kings County · 11209
05 · Commercial & OfficeSold $2,500,000 · May 2017 ↗
Owner of record
OwnerFifth Avenue Realty Holdings LLC
Assessment · 2025 roll
Land assessed$82,800
Total assessed$366,750
Est. annual tax$38,937 (2027, excl. special districts)
Building
StyleTwo Story or Store and Office
Year built1930
Lot
Size0.13 acres (GIS)
Frontage × depth52 × 100 ft
Lot sq ft5,250
Zoning
DistrictR6A
Commercial overlayC2-3
Special districtBR
FAR0.54 built · 3.0 max residential · 3.0 max facility
Zoning map22b
Recorded documents · 17
ASSIGNMENT OF LEASES AND RENTS
$1,050,000
Jun 8, 2017
assignor Fifth Avenue Realty Holdings LLC
assignee Flushing Bank
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
$2,500,000
Jun 8, 2017
grantor/seller 9419 5th Avenue Holdings LLC; D'Amato, Peter
grantee/buyer Fifth Avenue Realty Holdings LLC
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$1,050,000
Jun 8, 2017
mortgagor/borrower Fifth Avenue Realty Holdings LLC
mortgagee/lender Flushing Bank
View on ACRIS ↗Show all 17
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Jun 8, 2017
mortgager/borrower D'Amato, Salvatore
mortgagee/lender Independence Community Realty Corp.
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Apr 18, 2016
grantor/seller D'Amato, Sara
grantee/buyer 9419 5th Avenue Holdings LLC
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Jan 7, 2013
grantor/seller D'Amato, Anna
grantee/buyer D'Amato, Peter; D'Amato, Sara
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Dec 14, 2005
mortgager/borrower D'Amato, Salvatore
mortgagee/lender U.S. Small Business Administration
View on ACRIS ↗
AGREEMENT
Aug 21, 2002
party 1 Independence Community Realty Corp
party 2 D'Amato, Salvatore
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Aug 21, 2002
assignor/old lender Bay Ridge Federal Savings And Loan Association; Bay Ridge Federal Savings Bank
assignee/new lender Independence Community Realty Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$50,000
Aug 1, 2002
mortgagor/borrower D'Amato, Salvatore
mortgagee/lender Us Small Business Administration
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Aug 20, 1999
grantor/seller St Patrick'S Roman Catholic Church
grantee/buyer D'Amato, Salvatore
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Mar 10, 1987
assignor/old lender St. Patrick'S Rc Church
assignee/new lender Bay Ridge Federal S& L
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Jan 27, 1987
grantor/seller St Patrick'S Roman Catho
grantee/buyer D'Amato, Salvatore
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$300,000
Jan 27, 1987
mortgagor/borrower D'Amato, Salvatore
mortgagee/lender St.Patrick'S Rom/Cathol/
View on ACRIS ↗DOB violations — total 3 · open 3 · dismissed 0
Elevators
Active
Aug 29, 2025
BIS ↗Elevators
Active
Aug 29, 2025
BIS ↗Elevators
Active
Oct 23, 2023
BIS ↗DOB complaints — total 3 · open 0 · closed 3
Certificate of occupancy – none/illegal/contrary
Closed
Jan 18, 2008
Complaint 3251049
View on BIS ↗No HPD violations on file.
Deed & identifiers
SBL3061180005
SWIS610100
Parcel ID6101003061180005
Who owns 9419 5 Avenue?
9419 5 Avenue, Brooklyn is owned by Fifth Avenue Realty Holdings LLC per the 2025 NYS assessment roll. It last sold for $2,500,000 in May 2017.
Nearby on 5 Avenue
Public record, NYS tax roll 2025. Values are the assessor's, not an appraisal. Provided for informational purposes only — accuracy and completeness are not warranted or guaranteed; verify against official sources before relying on it. Disclaimer · Request redaction
Search by name or address · Browse all records