NY Property Records
242 Handsome Ave
242 Handsome Ave
Islip · Suffolk County
280 · ResidentialSold $2,185,000 · Feb 2026
Owner of record
OwnerJoel Cataldo
Mailing address242 HANDSOME AVE · SAYVILLE, NY, 11782
Assessment · 2025 roll
Land assessed$35,800
Total assessed$97,500
Est. annual tax$28,261 (2024, excl. special districts)
Lot
Size1.18 acres
Services & districts
School districtSayville (472804)
Recorded sales · 2
Deed$2,185,000Feb 5, 2026
seller JOEL CATALDO
buyer ROBERT MENZEL
Liber 13326, page 859
Deed$1,550,000Aug 31, 2021
seller ROBERT T MILLER
buyer JOEL CATALDO
Liber 13140, page 629
From NYS RP-5217 transfer reports. For the deed itself, use the liber and page at the county clerk.
Deed & identifiers
Deed book / page13140 / 629
SBL05004300008000050000
Print key430.-8-5
SWIS472889
Parcel ID47288905004300008000050000
Who owns 242 Handsome Ave?
242 Handsome Ave, Islip is owned by Joel Cataldo per the 2025 NYS assessment roll. It last sold for $2,185,000 in Feb 2026.
Nearby on Handsome Ave
Public record, NYS tax roll 2025. Values are the assessor's, not an appraisal. Provided for informational purposes only — accuracy and completeness are not warranted or guaranteed; verify against official sources before relying on it. Disclaimer · Request redaction
Search by name or address · Browse all records