NY Property Records
16 Bay Ave
16 Bay Ave
Shelter Island · Suffolk County · 11964
$2,259,000Full market value210 · Residential
Owner of record
OwnerThieringer Rev. Tst. James S
Mailing address177 Naughright Rd · Long Valley, NJ, 07853
Assessment · 2025 roll
Land assessed$677,000
Total assessed$2,259,000
Full market value$2,259,000
Est. annual tax$9,356 (2024, excl. special districts)
Building
StyleOther style
Year built1885
Living area3,047 sq ft
Bedrooms6
Full baths2
HeatHot wtr/stm
FuelOil
Lot
Size0.5 acres
Services & districts
WaterComm/public
SewerComm/public
UtilitiesElectric
School districtShelter Island (473201)
Recorded sales · 3
Deed$1May 28, 2024
seller RICHARD L. THIERINGER
buyer 2020 REVOCABLE TRUST THIERINGER,JAMES S. TTEE
Liber 13253, page 211
Deed$1May 16, 2020
seller JAMES THIERINGER (50 INTEREST)
buyer TRUSTEE(50INTEREST) JAMES S. THIERINGER AS
Liber 13079, page 371
Deed$1Nov 17, 2016
seller EXECUTOR OF ESTATE OF THIERINGER, JAMES S.
buyer RICHARD L. THIERINGER
Liber 12893, page 131
From NYS RP-5217 transfer reports. For the deed itself, use the liber and page at the county clerk.
Deed & identifiers
Deed book / page13253 / 211
SBL00500000020070000000
Print key5.-2-7
SWIS473289
Parcel ID47328900500000020070000000
Who owns 16 Bay Ave?
16 Bay Ave, Shelter Island is owned by Thieringer Rev. Tst. James S per the 2025 NYS assessment roll.
Nearby on Bay Ave
14 Bay Ave · 12 Bay Ave · 10 Bay Ave · 10 Bay Ave · 8 Bay Ave · 8 Bay Ave · 6 Bay Ave · 5 Bay Ave · 4 Bay Ave · 3 Bay Ave
Public record, NYS tax roll 2025. Values are the assessor's, not an appraisal. Provided for informational purposes only — accuracy and completeness are not warranted or guaranteed; verify against official sources before relying on it. Disclaimer · Request redaction
Search by name or address · Browse all records