NY Property Records
54 N Menantic Rd
54 N Menantic Rd
Shelter Island · Suffolk County · 11964
$1,494,000Full market value210 · Residential
Owner of record
OwnerTheinert, James M
AlsoTheinert, Mary
Mailing addressPO Box 108 · Shelter Island, NY, 119640108
Assessment · 2025 roll
Land assessed$340,000
Total assessed$1,494,000
Full market value$1,494,000
Est. annual tax$5,786 (2024, excl. special districts)
Building
StyleOld style
Year built1867
Living area2,023 sq ft
Bedrooms3
Full baths2
HeatHot wtr/stm
FuelOil
Lot
Size1.4 acres
Services & districts
WaterPrivate
SewerPrivate
UtilitiesElectric
School districtShelter Island (473201)
Recorded sales · 1
Deed$1Aug 23, 2024
seller JAMES M THEINERT
buyer JAMES M THEINERT
Liber 13271, page 807
From NYS RP-5217 transfer reports. For the deed itself, use the liber and page at the county clerk.
Deed & identifiers
Deed book / page13271 / 807
SBL01400000030520010000
Print key14.-3-52.1
SWIS473289
Parcel ID47328901400000030520010000
Who owns 54 N Menantic Rd?
54 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island is owned by Theinert, James M per the 2025 NYS assessment roll.
Nearby on N Menantic Rd
Public record, NYS tax roll 2025. Values are the assessor's, not an appraisal. Provided for informational purposes only — accuracy and completeness are not warranted or guaranteed; verify against official sources before relying on it. Disclaimer · Request redaction
Search by name or address · Browse all records