NY Property Records
5 Strawberry Ln
5 Strawberry Ln
Shelter Island · Suffolk County · 11964
$1,381,000Full market value210 · Residential
Owner of record
OwnerCaptain Don'S Paradise, LLC
Mailing address17 Whitney Farms Circle · Fairport, NY, 14450
Assessment · 2025 roll
Land assessed$337,000
Total assessed$1,381,000
Full market value$1,381,000
Est. annual tax$4,866 (2024, excl. special districts)
Building
StyleRanch
Year built1970
Living area1,600 sq ft
Bedrooms3
Full baths1
HeatHot air
FuelPropane/LPG
Lot
Size0.5 acres
Services & districts
WaterPrivate
SewerPrivate
UtilitiesElectric
School districtShelter Island (473201)
Recorded sales · 3
Deed$1Jul 10, 2023
seller McCarthy, Shaefer, Kehrig
buyer CAPTAIN DONS PARADISE LL
Liber 13234, page 199
Deed$1Mar 28, 2021
seller EILEEN M. MCCARTHY
buyer McCarthy Jr., Shafer,Kehrig,McCarthy,McCart
Liber 13103, page 61
Deed$1Feb 24, 2017
seller Donald Mc-Carthy
buyer Eileen McCarthy
Liber 12903, page 168
From NYS RP-5217 transfer reports. For the deed itself, use the liber and page at the county clerk.
Deed & identifiers
Deed book / page13234 / 199
SBL01900000020180000000
Print key19.-2-18
SWIS473289
Parcel ID47328901900000020180000000
Who owns 5 Strawberry Ln?
5 Strawberry Ln, Shelter Island is owned by Captain Don'S Paradise, LLC per the 2025 NYS assessment roll.
Nearby on Strawberry Ln
Public record, NYS tax roll 2025. Values are the assessor's, not an appraisal. Provided for informational purposes only — accuracy and completeness are not warranted or guaranteed; verify against official sources before relying on it. Disclaimer · Request redaction
Search by name or address · Browse all records