New York Ave, Shelter Island
- New York Ave S I Hts Property Owners Corp.
- New York Ave Town Of Shelter Island
- 22 New York Ave Rosamilia, Steven
- 26 New York Ave Demers, Debre'
- 28 New York Ave S I Hts Property Owners Corp.
- 28 New York Ave S I Hts Property Owners Corp.
- 29 New York Ave S I Hts Property Owners Corp.
- 30 New York Ave S I Hts Property Owners Corp.
- 31 New York Ave Haggerty, Dennis
- 32 New York Ave S I Hts Property Owners Corp.
- 33 New York Ave Daly, David
- 35 New York Ave Pellicano Family Irr. Trust
- 36 New York Ave 36 New York Ave Llc
- 37 New York Ave Dacosta, Antonio
- 39 New York Ave Carroll, William
- 40 New York Ave Shoulberg, Matthew
- 41 New York Ave Iden, Julie
- 42a New York Ave Schneider, Donald
- 45 New York Ave Mandell, Daniel J
- 47 New York Ave Young, Richard